Why Turkish Courts Refuse Enforcement of Foreign Judgments and Awards (2026): Refusal Grounds, Court of Cassation Decisions and How to Avoid a Refusal
13 November 2026

Why Turkish Courts Refuse Enforcement of Foreign Judgments and Awards (2026): Refusal Grounds, Court of Cassation Decisions and How to Avoid a Refusal

Refusal of enforcement in Turkey cannot rest on a finding that the foreign court decided the case wrongly: Turkish courts may not review the merits. Many enforcement actions run into trouble earlier and for avoidable reasons, such as security for costs not deposited, a certificate of finality missing or issued too late, a judgment served on a Turkish defendant by post, or reciprocity asserted but never proved. The substantive grounds, public policy above all, succeed less often than debtors hope, but they do succeed in identifiable situations: damages with a punitive element, a conflict with a final Turkish judgment, an award that contradicts directly applicable Turkish regulation. This guide sets out each ground with the Court of Cassation decisions that applied or rejected it, explains the difference between a dismissal and a refusal, and ends with a checklist for a petition built not to be refused. It reflects the legislation in force as at 13 November 2026.

Refusal of enforcement in Turkey at a glance

The conditions for enforcing a foreign judgment are set out in Articles 50 to 54 of Law No. 5718 on International Private and Procedural Law, and those for arbitral awards in Articles 60 to 62 and the New York Convention. The general rules are explained in Enforcement of Foreign Judgments in Turkey and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards in Turkey. This page looks at the same rules from the other side: where enforcement actually fails, and why.

Why enforcement actions fail in Turkey: the grounds and what follows

GroundBasisRaised byUsual resultCan it be put right?
Security for costs not depositedLaw No. 5718 Art. 48; Code of Civil Procedure Arts. 88(1), 114(1)(ğ)Court of its own motionDismissal on procedural groundsYes: plead the treaty exemption or deposit within the time limit
Documents missing or not certifiedLaw No. 5718 Art. 53Court of its own motionTime limit, then the action is treated as not filed or dismissedUsually, within the time limit
Judgment not final, or final only after filingLaw No. 5718 Arts. 50(1), 53(b)Court of its own motionDismissal or refusal; decisions differ on whether it can be cured during the actionFile only once final
Wrong court or wrong feeLaw No. 5718 Art. 51; Turkish Commercial Code Art. 5(3); Law on Fees Art. 32CourtTransfer to the competent court, or the action stalls until the fee is paidYes
No reciprocity provedLaw No. 5718 Art. 54(1)(a)Court of its own motionRefusal, or reversal on appeal for incomplete investigationOnly with evidence of the foreign law or practice
Exclusive Turkish jurisdictionArt. 54(1)(b), first limbCourt of its own motionRefusal, possibly of part onlyNo, for the affected part
No real connection with the foreign forumArt. 54(1)(b), second limbDebtor’s objection onlyRefusalAnswer with the jurisdiction clause and the connecting facts
Manifest breach of public policyArt. 54(1)(c)Court of its own motionRefusal of the whole or of the affected partSeek partial enforcement
Defective summons or default judgmentArt. 54(1)(ç)Debtor’s objection onlyRefusalOnly if service is proved under the law of origin

Key point: The grounds that the court examines of its own motion are where preparation pays: a petition that answers them on its face, with the documents annexed, leaves the debtor only the grounds that depend on its own objection.

Dismissed, refused or partly enforced: three outcomes

A creditor who reads “the court rejected our enforcement action” needs to know which of three things happened, because the next step depends on it. Article 56 of Law No. 5718 allows the court to enforce the judgment in whole or in part or to refuse the request. Separately, the Code of Civil Procedure lets the court end an action without examining the request at all when a procedural prerequisite is missing.

The three outcomes and what each means

OutcomeTurkish termBasisWhat it decidesNext step
Dismissal on procedural grounds, or action treated as not filedusulden ret; açılmamış sayılmaCode of Civil Procedure Arts. 88(1), 115(2), 119(2); Art. 20 for transfersNothing about whether the judgment meets the conditionsCure the defect and file again, or appeal if the dismissal was wrong
Refusal of the requestistemin reddiLaw No. 5718 Arts. 54 and 56That one or more conditions of enforcement are not metAppeal within two weeks; a final refusal binds the parties on the same request
Partial enforcementkısmen tenfizLaw No. 5718 Art. 56Which parts of the judgment can be executed in TurkeyExecute the enforced part once final; appeal the refused part if it is worth it

The distinction matters most after the event. A dismissal on procedural grounds does not settle the dispute and can be followed by a new action once the defect is cured. A final judgment produces res judicata only where the parties, the cause of action and the relief sought in the second action are the same as in the first (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 303(1)), and the absence of an earlier final judgment on the same claim is itself a procedural prerequisite (Art. 114(1)(i)). A request refused on the substantive conditions therefore cannot simply be filed again on the same facts. The route is the appeal.

Procedural dismissals: security, documents, fee and court

Commentary on Turkish practice identifies procedure as the area where most problems arise (Tarman 2023). The failures below stop the action before the court reaches the conditions in Article 54, and all of them can be prevented.

Security for costs not deposited

Foreign natural and legal persons who bring an action in Turkey must provide the security that the court sets, unless exempt on the basis of reciprocity (Law No. 5718 Art. 48). Compliance with an order for security is a procedural prerequisite (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 114(1)(ğ)), and if the security is not provided within the final time limit set by the judge, the action is dismissed on procedural grounds (Art. 88(1)). The exemption usually comes from a treaty, but whether a treaty covers companies has been contested. The 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation at one time read Article 17 of the 1954 Hague Convention on Civil Procedure as covering natural persons only (E.2015/26555, K.2016/3489, 11 February 2016, and E.2013/17436, K.2013/24686, 2 July 2013, as reported by Tarman 2023) and later applied it to legal persons as well (E.2017/8463, K.2017/15601, 14 December 2017, as published). Commentary in 2023 still described the narrower reading as the Court’s approach, so the point should be argued, not assumed. How the exemption works for UK, German and US claimants is explained in the UK guide, the German guide and the US guide.

Documents missing, uncertified or badly translated

The petition must be accompanied by the judgment, as an original certified by the authorities of the state of origin or a copy certified by the court that gave it, and by a certified document showing that it is final, each with a certified translation (Law No. 5718 Art. 53). Courts have not treated a gap in these documents uniformly. The 11th Civil Chamber has given the claimant a one-week final time limit under Article 119(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure and held that the action is treated as not filed if the documents are not produced within it (E.2017/4818, K.2017/7059, 11 December 2017); older decisions of the 2nd Civil Chamber treated the gap as a missing procedural prerequisite and dismissed the action (both as reported by Tarman 2023).

Two practical points come out of the same commentary. Some courts ask for an apostille on every document even where a bilateral treaty exempts documents of the other state from legalisation, as Turkey’s treaties with Poland and several other states do; and translations of legal terms are a frequent source of delay. A related point concerns the operative part. Judgments from some countries, Germany for example, state the operative part first and the reasons afterwards. Execution offices used to Turkish judgments, where the operative part comes at the end, can misread them, so the petition should ask the court to state clearly what is enforced.

The wrong court fee

For a money judgment the court fee is proportional: 68.31 per thousand of the amount awarded, one quarter on filing. Whether a percentage fee could be charged in an enforcement action was long disputed, and some chamber decisions applied a fixed fee; the Constitutional Court rejected a challenge to Article 4 of the Law on Fees on 17 October 2024 (E.2024/104, K.2024/173). In 2020 the Kayseri Regional Court of Appeal returned a file to the first instance court because the claimant had paid a fixed fee where a proportional fee was due (6th Civil Chamber, E.2020/131, K.2020/14, 31 January 2020, as reported by Tarman 2023). No further step is taken in proceedings until the fees due are paid (Law on Fees No. 492, Art. 32). Foreign arbitral awards attract a fixed fee. Both rules, with a calculator, are in Cost of Enforcing a Foreign Judgment or Award in Turkey.

The wrong court

The court with jurisdiction over enforcement is the court of first instance at the debtor’s domicile or residence in Turkey, failing which a court in Ankara, Istanbul or Izmir (Law No. 5718 Art. 51). For a commercial judgment that means the commercial court of first instance: the relationship between commercial and civil courts is one of subject-matter jurisdiction (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 5(3)), and a judgment on an industrial property right goes to the specialised intellectual and industrial property court, as the regional court of appeal held in the Paris trademark case discussed below (Industrial Property Law No. 6769, Art. 156). Filing in the wrong court leads to a decision declining jurisdiction. The file is then transferred only if a party applies within two weeks of that decision becoming final; otherwise the action is treated as not filed (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 20(1)).

Mandatory mediation is not required

Mediation before suit is a procedural prerequisite for commercial claims whose subject is the payment of money (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 5/A). An enforcement action is not such a claim: it asks for an enforcement decision, not an order to pay. The Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal rejected a debtor’s mediation objection on that basis, noting that the statute does not list enforcement actions among the claims subject to mandatory mediation (14th Civil Chamber, E.2024/910, K.2024/1595, 12 November 2024, by majority, as published). A practice of requiring mediation where the foreign judgment concerned a commercial, consumer or employment dispute has been observed and criticised in commentary (Tarman 2023).

Finality: the judgment must be final, and final in time

Only judgments that are final under the law of the state of origin can be enforced (Law No. 5718 Art. 50(1)), and finality must be shown by a certified document (Art. 53(b)). Provisional enforceability in the state of origin is not enough. Two problems recur.

Finality reached after the action was filed. The Court of Cassation has not been consistent on whether finality must exist when the action is brought. The 2nd Civil Chamber held that it must, and that the defect cannot be cured during the action (E.2003/495, K.2003/1706, 6 February 2003); the 11th Civil Chamber treated it as a procedural defect that the claimant should be allowed to cure (E.2008/1586, K.2009/6229, 22 May 2009, not published), both as reported by Şit 2011. In more recent cases the chamber and the General Assembly of Civil Chambers have asked whether the judgment became final before the action was filed (see the Dortmund and Cologne cases below). The safe course is plain: do not file until the judgment is final, and file the document that shows the date.

Finality that depends on service. In many systems the time for appeal runs from service of the judgment, so a defective service of the judgment itself can mean that it never became final. In a case on a judgment of the regional court in Dortmund, the judgment had been sent to the Turkish defendant directly by post, and the first instance court refused enforcement on the ground that a judgment served in a way Turkey does not accept had not become final. The 11th Civil Chamber first upheld the refusal but, on rectification, reversed it: the court had to investigate, if necessary through the Ministry of Justice or by letters rogatory to the German court, whether a later service through the Ministry under the Hague Convention covered the judgment itself or only a later correction decision, and whether finality occurred before the action was filed. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers upheld that approach (E.2017/93, K.2018/486, 14 March 2018, as published).

Practical consequence: Ask the foreign court or your counsel there for a certificate of finality that states the date of finality and, where appeal time runs from service, how and when the judgment was served. Serve a judgment on a Turkish debtor through the Turkish Central Authority, not by post, before relying on its finality.

Is it a court judgment? Payment orders and interim orders

Article 50 speaks of judgments given by foreign courts in civil matters. Debtors sometimes argue that a title produced in a summary procedure is not a judgment. The Court of Cassation has looked at the effect of the title under the law of origin rather than its form:

  • A Warsaw court’s order for payment, issued without a hearing in a written summary procedure after the debtor failed to object in time, was held enforceable. The 19th Civil Chamber had reversed the first instance decision granting enforcement; on rectification the 11th Civil Chamber lifted that reversal, holding that the absence of an equivalent procedure in Turkish law did not make enforcement contrary to public policy and that a difference in procedure alone cannot do so (E.2020/6061, K.2021/6271, 17 November 2021, by majority; a dissenting member considered that a payment order issued without proceedings is not a judicial decision; as published).
  • A German Vollstreckungsbescheid signed by a court officer rather than a judge was held enforceable in 2025 (3rd Civil Chamber, E.2025/452, K.2025/4021, 11 September 2025); the facts are set out in Enforcing a German Judgment in Turkey.
  • Interim measures are different. A foreign freezing order or interim injunction is provisional and not final, so it cannot be enforced under Article 50 (Tarman 2023). Assets in Turkey are protected with Turkish interim measures instead; see Freezing Assets in Turkey for Investor Claims.

Reciprocity: refusals and reversals

Reciprocity, required for enforcement but not for recognition (Law No. 5718 Arts. 54(1)(a) and 58(1)), is the condition on which many enforcement actions are decided. The decisions point in two directions at once: the court must investigate it, and the claimant who does not prove it bears the risk.

  • Investigation is the court’s duty. The Court of Cassation reversed a decision granting enforcement of an Alabama judgment because the court had not investigated whether Alabama law allowed Turkish judgments to be enforced (2nd Civil Chamber, E.1996/2955, K.1996/5085, 14 May 1996, as reported). The Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal has stated that reciprocity is to be investigated of the court’s own motion (44th Civil Chamber, E.2020/1339, K.2022/1753, 15 December 2022, as reported by Çörtoğlu Koca 2025).
  • The Ministry’s opinion does not decide it. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers has held that the opinion of the Ministry of Justice on reciprocity, which courts often request, does not bind the court (E.1990/13-3, K.1990/347, 13 June 1990, as reported).
  • Actual practice can defeat a treaty or a statute. The 11th Civil Chamber has held reciprocity not established where it was shown that, in fact, Turkish judgments were not enforced in the state concerned, despite a legal or treaty basis (E.2008/1284, K.2009/980, 30 January 2009, as reported by Tarman 2023). Where legal or treaty reciprocity exists, the mere absence of any precedent, because no Turkish judgment has yet been taken there, is not an obstacle (Tarman 2023).

Practical consequence: Do not leave reciprocity to the court’s investigation, which takes months. Annex the foreign statute and any foreign decision enforcing a Turkish judgment, with certified translations. For the United States, prove it for the state concerned; see Enforcing a US Judgment in Turkey.

Public policy: what has and has not succeeded

Enforcement is refused only if the judgment is manifestly contrary to public policy (Law No. 5718 Art. 54(1)(c)). In its 2012 unification decision the Court of Cassation held that the test is the effect that execution of the judgment would have in Turkey, measured against the fundamental values of Turkish law, and that a breach of a mandatory Turkish rule is not in itself a breach of public policy (Grand General Assembly on the Unification of Judgments, 10 February 2012, E.2010/1, K.2012/1, published in the Official Gazette of 20 September 2012). The court may not review the merits, and commentary has criticised first instance courts that appoint experts to examine the content of the foreign judgment under the heading of public policy (Tarman 2023).

Public policy objections against foreign court judgments: decisions

DecisionObjection or issueOutcome
Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E.2021/1358, K.2022/2968, 31 May 2022 (as reported by Çörtoğlu Koca 2025)Damages with a punitive elementRefused: incompatible with the compensatory principle of the Turkish Code of Obligations, Arts. 49 et seq.
Grand General Assembly on the Unification of Judgments, 10 February 2012, E.2010/1, K.2012/1Judgment without reasonsEnforceable: lack of reasons alone is not a manifest breach of public policy
11th Civil Chamber, E.2020/6061, K.2021/6271, 17 November 2021 (majority)Polish payment order issued without a hearingEnforceable: a difference in procedure is not a breach of public policy
11th Civil Chamber, E.2009/14645, K.2011/16711, 9 December 2011 (as reported in the 2024 General Assembly decision)Alleged conflict with Turkish judgmentsRefusal reversed: a conflict with a Turkish judgment between the same parties on the same subject and cause bars enforcement; other Turkish decisions do not on their own
11th Civil Chamber, E.2022/3126, K.2023/6729, 22 November 2023 (as reported by Çörtoğlu Koca 2025)Paris judgment on trademark infringement; bias and non-application of Turkish law allegedEnforced: the court does not examine which law the foreign court applied or how
Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 14th Civil Chamber, E.2024/910, K.2024/1595, 12 November 2024 (majority)Baku commercial court judgment; forged documents and wrong assessment of evidence allegedEnforced: these are merits questions; no concrete breach of fair trial shown

Two further points from commentary are worth knowing. The financial hardship that execution would cause the debtor, even the loss of most of its assets, is not a breach of public policy (Çörtoğlu Koca 2025). And commentary has argued that a judgment should not be refused merely because it awards punitive damages, since Turkish law itself provides for treble damages in competition and copyright law, and that public policy should intervene where the award exceeds three times the loss or is otherwise excessive (Tarman 2017). The 2022 decision of the 6th Civil Chamber shows that courts can take a stricter view. The practical answer to a punitive element is partial enforcement of the compensatory part, discussed below.

Service and default judgments

If the debtor objects, enforcement is refused where, under the law of the state of origin, the debtor was not duly summoned or represented, or was judged in its absence contrary to that law (Law No. 5718 Art. 54(1)(ç)). The objection has to be raised; the court does not take it of its own motion. Three lines of decisions explain how it works in practice.

  • Postal service on a defendant in Turkey. Turkey objected to the methods of service in Article 10 of the Hague Service Convention of 15 November 1965, including direct service by post. The 11th Civil Chamber has treated service by post on a defendant in Turkey as invalid where the finality of the judgment depended on it, so that, on the debtor’s objection, it bars enforcement (E.2018/3992, K.2020/1847, 20 February 2020; E.2015/1049, K.2015/2238, 19 February 2015; E.2012/3175, K.2012/5547, 6 April 2012, as reported by Tarman 2023).
  • A properly served default judgment is enforceable. In the Cologne case described below, the General Assembly of Civil Chambers held that whether a default judgment was validly given is assessed under the law of the state of origin; the defendant had been served in accordance with the Hague Convention and the German court had given judgment in default under § 331(3) of the German Code of Civil Procedure, which was no obstacle (E.2019/11-272, K.2019/1396, 19 December 2019, as reported in the 2024 decision).
  • An unexplained objection fails. The Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal rejected a service objection where the debtor did not explain why service was invalid and did not show that it had applied to the foreign court or appealed (E.2024/910, K.2024/1595, 12 November 2024).

Commentary adds two points. A defendant who was duly served and chose not to appear should not be able to rely on the ground later (Tarman 2023, citing Nomer). And because the debtor cannot be asked to prove a negative, once it alleges defective service the creditor should prove proper service with the service records themselves; a statement in the judgment that the defendant was duly served is not enough (Çörtoğlu Koca 2025). How service on Turkish defendants is carried out is explained in Service of Documents in Turkish Proceedings.

Exclusive jurisdiction and real connection

A judgment on a matter within the exclusive jurisdiction of Turkish courts is not enforced, and the court examines this of its own motion (Law No. 5718 Art. 54(1)(b), first limb). Ordinary commercial money claims are not within it. The decisions on intellectual property show where the line runs:

  • Claims for damages for infringement of a trademark are not within exclusive Turkish jurisdiction, so a Paris judgment awarding damages was enforced (11th Civil Chamber, E.2022/3126, K.2023/6729, 22 November 2023), as were costs-fixing decisions given in German patent infringement proceedings (General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E.2017/11-52, K.2021/671, 3 June 2021), both as reported by Çörtoğlu Koca 2025.
  • Actions brought by third parties against the holder of a Turkish industrial property right, such as invalidity actions, are in the view taken in commentary within exclusive Turkish jurisdiction (Industrial Property Law No. 6769, Art. 156(5)), and a foreign judgment on them is exposed to refusal (Çörtoğlu Koca 2025).

A risk to watch in transport and distribution disputes: in jurisdiction disputes between 2020 and 2022 the 11th Civil Chamber read the last sentence of Article 105(2) of the Turkish Commercial Code, on agents of foreign traders, as an exclusive jurisdiction rule and refused effect to foreign jurisdiction and arbitration clauses in claims involving the Turkish agents of foreign carriers (as reported by S. Özel and C. Yöney, Marmara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Hukuk Araştırmaları Dergisi 30(1), 2024, pp. 229–249). We have not seen that reading applied to refuse enforcement of a foreign judgment, but a debtor sued as agent can be expected to argue it.

The second limb, a foreign court that took jurisdiction without any real connection with the subject matter or the parties, applies only on the debtor’s objection. A jurisdiction clause, the place of performance or the debtor’s business in the state of origin answers it. In the material reviewed for this guide we did not find a reported Court of Cassation decision refusing enforcement on this ground alone.

Partial enforcement and requests outside the judgment

The court may enforce a judgment in part (Law No. 5718 Art. 56), and partial enforcement is often the answer to an objection that affects only one element. In a 2014 decision of the 11th Civil Chamber on a French judgment for trademark infringement, enforcement was granted for the damages and the monetary penalty and refused for the orders to remove the infringement and to publish the judgment, which by their nature could be carried out only in France (E.2014/1376, K.2014/4242, 6 March 2014, as reported by Çörtoğlu Koca 2025). The same logic lets a creditor ask for the compensatory part of a judgment that also contains punitive damages, and leave out sums already paid, which the debtor may raise as a defence (Art. 55(2)).

The opposite mistake is to ask for more than the judgment gives. In the Paris trademark case the petition had also asked for collection of the 30,000 euros with interest from the date of the judgment, although the French judgment contained no order to that effect. The regional court of appeal partly rejected the action on that point and ordered the claimant to pay the debtor’s attorney’s fee for it. The 11th Civil Chamber struck out the partial rejection and the fee, because the claimant had clarified at the preliminary hearing that it sought enforcement of the damages alone (E.2022/3126, K.2023/6729, 22 November 2023, as reported by Çörtoğlu Koca 2025).

Practical consequence: Ask for enforcement of exactly what the foreign judgment orders, identified by the paragraphs of its operative part, and do not combine it with a request for collection or for interest that the judgment does not provide for. Collection follows in execution proceedings; see Enforcing a Money Judgment in Turkey.

Has a Turkish court dismissed or refused your enforcement action?

Hukukçular Evi Ankara reviews the decision, the time left for appeal and whether the defect can be cured. Call or WhatsApp +90 554 648 37 15.

📞 +90 554 648 37 15💬 WhatsApp

Arbitral awards: refusals and reversals

The grounds for refusing a foreign award are listed in Article 62(1) of Law No. 5718 and Article V of the New York Convention. The burden of proving the grounds relating to representation, notice, the validity of the arbitration agreement, the procedure, the scope of the award and its binding force lies on the party resisting enforcement (Art. 62(2)). Public policy and arbitrability are not on that list and are examined by the court. Reported decisions show that public policy succeeds against awards in a few defined situations and fails when it is used to reopen the merits.

Public policy objections against foreign arbitral awards: decisions

DecisionIssueOutcome
11th Civil Chamber, E.2006/7396, K.2007/6672, 1 May 2007 (as reported by Ekşi 2020)ICC award ordering repayment of VAT on the basis that the contract was exempt, contrary to a final Turkish tax court decisionGrant reversed; enforcement to be refused
19th Civil Chamber, E.2017/4228, K.2018/1042, 28 February 2018 (as reported by Ekşi 2020)English award on a maize sale; GMO tests under Biosafety Law No. 5977Refusal upheld: the GMO rules are directly applicable public policy rules
15th Civil Chamber, E.2014/2183, K.2014/3226, 12 May 2014 (as reported by Ekşi 2020)Penalty clause said to be excessive for the guarantorsRefusal reversed: excessiveness under the former Code of Obligations is not public policy
11th Civil Chamber, E.2016/14160, K.2018/7501, 29 November 2018 (as reported by Ekşi 2020)Alleged conflict of two ICC awards with a Turkish criminal acquittal; fair trialThe chamber did not accept that the acquittal conflicted with the awards
11th Civil Chamber, E.2015/11441, K.2016/8701, 16 November 2016 (not published; as reported by Tarman 2017)Sole arbitrator from a German-speaking Swiss canton; claimant a German companyRefusal reversed: no concrete facts on impartiality
General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E.19-467, K.489, 9 June 1999 (as reported by Ekşi 2020)Clause giving the right to choose between two arbitral institutions to whichever party brings the claimNot contrary to public policy
11th Civil Chamber, E.2020/2115, K.2022/1276, 24 February 2022ICC award on costs; objection that the costs were unsubstantiatedEnforced: the objection was abstract

The 2022 decision is discussed in the arbitral awards guide, with the rules on documents, the fixed court fee and appeals. An award set aside at the seat is refused (Art. 62(1)(h)), so a pending annulment action abroad should be monitored.

How long a contested case can take: one judgment from 2006 to 2024

The history of one enforcement action, published with the General Assembly’s 2024 decision, shows what repeated refusals and reversals cost. The judgment was given by the regional court in Cologne on 16 February 2006 against a Turkish joint stock company; the enforcement action was heard by the 3rd Civil Court of First Instance in Konya.

A Cologne judgment in the Turkish courts (as published)

DateCourtResult
5 May 2009Konya court of first instanceRefused: conflict with Turkish judgments and public policy
9 December 201111th Civil ChamberReversed: no review of the merits; only a Turkish judgment on the same parties, subject and cause bars enforcement
11 December 2012Konya courtEnforcement granted
5 June 201311th Civil ChamberReversed: finality endorsement and certified documents not filed; fee miscalculated
23 February 2016Konya courtRefused: judgment said to have become final after the action was filed
4 October 201611th Civil ChamberReversed: defect cured during the action; judgment final before filing
11 October 2018Konya courtResisted the reversal
19 December 2019General Assembly of Civil ChambersResistance overturned: default judgment valid under German law after Hague-compliant service
29 December 2020Konya courtEnforcement granted
21 March 202211th Civil Chamber (majority)Reversed: enforcement held contrary to public policy under a 2019 statutory provision
16 February 2023Konya courtResisted again
17 April 2024General Assembly of Civil ChambersFile returned to the chamber after the Constitutional Court annulled the provision

The 2022 reversal relied on Provisional Article 4 added to Law No. 3332 by Law No. 7194 in 2019, which treated payments made to certain companies as share payments and required pending claims of that kind to be closed without a ruling. The Constitutional Court annulled its first paragraph (E.2020/11, K.2023/98, 18 May 2023, published on 12 September 2023), and the General Assembly sent the file back for examination in the light of the annulment (E.2023/780, K.2024/189, 17 April 2024, as published). The later course of the case is not reported in the sources we consulted.

Lesson: Two of the reversals in this case were about documents and finality, which a complete petition would have avoided. The others show that a contested case can run for more than a decade, which is why the debtor’s assets should be secured while it runs.

After a refusal: appeal, cure and re-file, or start again

Appeal. Decisions granting or refusing enforcement are open to appeal under the general rules (Law No. 5718 Art. 57(2)): to the regional court of appeal within two weeks of service of the decision (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 345), and from there, where available, to the Court of Cassation within two weeks (Art. 361). Several reversals in the decisions above did not end the case but sent it back for an investigation the first court had not carried out, of reciprocity or of service, so an appeal is worth assessing even where the facts are not fully in the file.

Cure and file again. After a dismissal on procedural grounds or a decision treating the action as not filed, the creditor can bring a new action once the defect is cured: the security deposited, the documents certified and translated, the fee paid. The cost is time, and the costs order in the first action.

Where the refusal is final. A final refusal binds the parties on the same request (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 303(1)). Res judicata requires the same parties, cause of action and relief, so whether a later request based on new facts is barred depends on the reasoning of the refusal, which counsel should read before anything is filed. Two alternatives remain, and they pull in different directions. Recognition does not require reciprocity (Law No. 5718 Art. 58(1)); it gives the judgment the effect of conclusive evidence or res judicata but does not make it enforceable. Conversely, a foreign judgment that has not been recognised has no such effect in Turkey (Art. 58(1)), so a new action on the underlying claim before a Turkish court is possible in principle, subject to Turkish jurisdiction, any jurisdiction or arbitration clause and limitation. Which route fits depends on why enforcement failed, and whether the foreign proceedings interrupted limitation should be checked first. On where to sue, see Suing in Turkey or Abroad.

Whatever the route, the debtor’s assets can be protected meanwhile by precautionary attachment and, if the debtor is heading for restructuring, by early action in the concordat proceedings; see Freezing a Turkish Debtor’s Assets Before Enforcement, Freezing Assets in Turkey and Insolvency and Concordat in Turkey.

A petition built to avoid refusal

  1. The judgment, certified by the authorities of the state of origin or by the court that gave it, with an apostille unless a treaty exempts it, and a certified Turkish translation.
  2. A certificate of finality showing the date of finality, obtained before the action is filed, with the record of service of the judgment where appeal time runs from service.
  3. Proof of service of the claim on the debtor through the Turkish Central Authority or another route Turkey accepts, or proof that the debtor appeared through counsel.
  4. Evidence of reciprocity: the treaty, or the foreign statute and decisions enforcing Turkish judgments, translated.
  5. The treaty relied on for exemption from security, or funds ready to deposit within the time limit.
  6. The proportional court fee, a quarter on filing, calculated on the Turkish lira equivalent stated in the petition.
  7. The correct court: the commercial court at the debtor’s domicile for a commercial judgment, or Ankara, Istanbul or Izmir if the debtor has neither domicile nor residence in Turkey.
  8. A request limited to what the judgment orders, identified by paragraph, leaving out punitive elements and sums already paid.
  9. A short answer, in the petition itself, to the objections the debtor is likely to raise: jurisdiction, public policy, service.
  10. A plan for the debtor’s assets while the action and any appeal run, since the appeal suspends execution (Law No. 5718 Art. 57(2)).

The documents needed for each country and the costs are explained in the general guide, the UK guide, the German guide and the US guide.

Working with counsel in Turkey

Hukukçular Evi Ankara is an Ankara-based law office (Av. Fatma Öztürk). It represents clients in enforcement actions before Turkish courts, in appeals against decisions dismissing or refusing enforcement, and in the execution proceedings that follow, and corresponds with foreign clients and their counsel in English. The office can be reached by telephone and WhatsApp on +90 554 648 37 15. To review a refusal, the useful documents are the Turkish decision and the date it was served, the petition and its annexes, the debtor’s response and the foreign judgment. Who may act for a foreign client and how powers of attorney are issued abroad are explained in Representing Foreign Institutional Investors in Turkish Capital Markets Disputes.

Frequently asked questions

Why do Turkish courts refuse enforcement of foreign judgments?

Many failures are procedural: security not deposited, documents missing or uncertified, a judgment not yet final, the wrong court or fee. Of the substantive grounds, reciprocity, public policy and defective service are the ones that decide cases (Law No. 5718 Arts. 48, 50–54).

Is a dismissal on procedural grounds the end of the matter?

No. It does not decide whether the conditions are met. Once the defect is cured, a new action can be filed; the loss is time and costs.

Can missing documents be filed after the action is brought?

Usually, within the time limit the court sets. The 11th Civil Chamber has applied the one-week limit in Code of Civil Procedure Art. 119(2), after which the action is treated as not filed.

Can we file before the foreign judgment is final?

Do not. Decisions differ on whether finality can be reached during the action, and the 2nd Civil Chamber has held that it cannot. File once final, with a certificate showing the date.

What happens if the court orders security and we do not deposit it?

The action is dismissed on procedural grounds once the final time limit expires (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 88(1)). Plead any treaty exemption at the outset.

Is mediation required before an enforcement action?

No. Mandatory mediation applies to commercial money claims (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 5/A), not to an action for an enforcement decision, as the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal held in 2024.

Can the debtor argue that the foreign court got the facts or the law wrong?

No. The Turkish court does not review the merits or which law the foreign court applied. Allegations about evidence or forged documents are merits questions unless they show a concrete breach of fair trial.

Are punitive damages enforced in Turkey?

A judgment with a punitive element has been refused as incompatible with the Turkish Code of Obligations (6th Civil Chamber, 2022). Seek partial enforcement of the compensatory part.

Can a default judgment against a Turkish company be refused?

Yes, if the debtor objects and service was defective under the law of origin. Service by post on a defendant in Turkey has been treated as invalid; service through the Central Authority is safe.

Will a foreign payment order or Vollstreckungsbescheid be enforced?

The Court of Cassation enforced a Polish payment order in 2021 and a German Vollstreckungsbescheid in 2025, looking at their effect under the law of origin.

Does a conflicting Turkish judgment bar enforcement?

A Turkish judgment between the same parties on the same subject and cause does; other Turkish decisions do not on their own (11th Civil Chamber, 2011). For awards, a conflict with a final Turkish tax court decision led to refusal.

Can the court enforce only part of the judgment?

Yes (Law No. 5718 Art. 56). A French judgment was enforced as to damages and refused as to removal and publication orders that could be executed only in France.

Can we ask the Turkish court to add interest?

No. Interest is enforced if the foreign judgment awards it. A request for more than the judgment gives can be partly rejected, with costs.

What can we do after a refusal?

Appeal within two weeks of service (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 345). If the refusal is final, consider recognition or a new action on the claim in Turkey, after checking limitation.

How long can a contested enforcement case take?

A Cologne judgment of 2006 was still before the Court of Cassation in 2024 after repeated refusals and reversals, as published with the 2024 General Assembly decision.

Hukukçular Evi Ankara

Ankara-based law office, Av. Fatma Öztürk. Telephone and WhatsApp: +90 554 648 37 15. We correspond in English.

📞 +90 554 648 37 15💬 WhatsApp

Guide in Turkish on the same subject: Yabancı Mahkeme ve Hakem Kararlarının Tanınması ve Tenfizi (MÖHUK m.50-63).

Official texts and published decisions referred to in this guide: Law No. 5718 on International Private and Procedural Law (in Turkish); Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (in Turkish); Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (in Turkish); Law on Fees No. 492 (in Turkish); Turkish Ministry of Justice list of exemptions from security (in Turkish); Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 14th Civil Chamber, E.2024/910, K.2024/1595 (in Turkish); Tarman 2023 (in Turkish).

Important note: This guide is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice on any matter. It reflects Turkish legislation in force as at 13 November 2026. Decisions marked “as reported” are cited from the commentary named, and their full texts were not available to us; the outcome of each case depends on its facts. Legislation relied on: Law No. 5718, Arts. 48, 50–58 and 60–62; Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Arts. 20, 88, 114, 115, 119, 303, 345 and 361; Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, Arts. 5, 5/A and 105; Law on Fees No. 492, Art. 32; Industrial Property Law No. 6769, Art. 156; Law No. 3332, Provisional Art. 4; Hague Convention on Civil Procedure of 1 March 1954, Art. 17; Hague Service Convention of 15 November 1965, Art. 10; New York Convention of 1958, Art. V. Commentary relied on: Z. D. Tarman, “Yabancı Mahkeme Kararlarının Tanınması ve Tenfizinde Sıklıkla Karşılaşılan Hukuki Sorunlar ve Çözüm Önerileri”, İnönü Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 14(1), 2023, pp. 73–86; Z. D. Tarman, “Yabancı Mahkeme ve Hakem Kararlarının Türkiye’de Tenfizinde Karşılaşılan Sorunlara İlişkin Bazı Tespitler”, Public and Private International Law Bulletin 37(2), 2017, pp. 798–820; N. Ekşi, “Yargıtay Kararları Işığında Yabancı Hakem Kararlarının Tenfizinde Kamu Düzeni”, Public and Private International Law Bulletin 40(1), 2020, pp. 143–201; S. Çörtoğlu Koca, “Sınai Mülkiyet Haklarına İlişkin Yabancı Mahkeme Kararlarının Tanınması ve Tenfizinde Münhasır Yetki Sorunu”, Başkent Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 11(1), 2025, pp. 1–20; B. Şit, “Yabancı Mahkeme Kararlarının Tanınması ve Tenfizinde Kesinleşme Şartı”, Gazi Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi XV(1), 2011; S. Özel and C. Yöney, Marmara Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Hukuk Araştırmaları Dergisi 30(1), 2024, pp. 229–249.

Post by Av. Fatma Öztürk